Двойные стандарты прессы: Stellar Blade против GTA 6

Игроки заметили контраст в оценках западной прессы: Еву из Stellar Blade критиковали, а Лусию и Мэнди из GTA 6 хвалят. Разбираем ситуацию подробно.

Players accuse Western press of double standards over Stellar Blade and GTA 6

The debate about objectivity in game media has flared up again. Users on Reddit and X compared how Western journalists wrote about the heroines of Stellar Blade and GTA 6 and found the tone suspiciously different. According to PlayGround, the trigger was fresh coverage from Kotaku and Destructoid.

What the complaint is about

In their GTA 6 pieces, the outlets describe Lucia enthusiastically: they praise her figure, call the character hot and speak warmly about how the intimate scenes with her are handled. The wording itself is not the issue. What bothers players is the context — two years earlier, the same press described the heroine of Stellar Blade in a very different way.

The objection is not that journalists liked Lucia. The argument is about criteria: if frankness is a problem on its own, it should stay a problem regardless of a project's budget. If it instead depends on context and artistic intent, that reasoning should be spelled out in every piece, not applied case by case.

Eva then, Lucia now

In 2024, the Korean studio Shift Up was criticised over Eva's design. Her tight outfits were called excessive fetishisation, and the developers were accused of pandering to the male gaze. An IGN France journalist went further, saying the developers had never seen a living woman — the outlet later had to issue an official apology.

Now, users note, similar choices in GTA 6 draw no complaints. Frankness is presented as a strength and discussed with interest.

Mandy, the bikini and the viral wave

A separate point of contention is Mandy, a secondary character. She appears in a revealing bikini, and Western outlets greeted her enthusiastically, backing the wave of her popularity on social media and publishing interviews with her actress. Yet comparable openness in the Korean action game was framed as objectification.

Players also point out that GTA 6 has more explicit content overall:

  • beach scenes;
  • strip clubs;
  • full sex scenes.

None of it has drawn accusations of objectification aimed at Rockstar.

The players' logic is simple: if a character's outfit alone makes a game objectifying, Mandy's bikini is no better than Eva's skin-tight suits. If presentation is what matters, the press should explain how Rockstar's approach differs from Shift Up's.

Why small studios take the hit

Users believe the answer lies in scale. A small Korean studio was easy to criticise, while going after Rockstar Games and the biggest release of the decade is something the specialist press is not prepared to do. That remains a player theory rather than a confirmed fact, but it is what keeps the thread alive.

They also note that the criticism of Stellar Blade came when the project had a far smaller budget and far less media protection. A small team simply has no resources to answer a wave of publications.

The dispute is not about whether sexuality belongs in games. It is about how evenly outlets apply their own standards. When the same wording becomes grounds for criticism in one case and for praise in another, audiences notice quickly.

What it means for players

The practical takeaway is simple: when reading reviews, separate the verdict on the game from the verdict on its aesthetics. If the tone around a heroine shifts sharply depending on the size of the studio, that is a signal you are looking at an editorial stance rather than analysis. Gameplay, systems and technical state deserve attention first — all GTA 6 coverage will help you build the full picture without extra labels.

For GTA 6 the argument matters because noise around the release is constant. The louder the discussion of how characters look, the less room is left for what the game actually does and offers.